Jack Brymer in London - the 1980's
It can be even worse when the intonation of a particular phrase or scale played solo comes under the microscope, because personal methods of correction become involved... There was a particularly glaring example of this in London recently when the final pianissimo D flat in a tiny clarinet interjection in Beethoven's Fifth came under the magnifier. It was sharp - predictably, because that's what happens to a clarinet when you do a special pianissimo. The player of course knew this, and the next time *Parkinson came around he played it just a reasonable piano in dynamic - in tune. The … more >>
It can be even worse when the intonation of a particular phrase or scale played solo comes under the microscope, because personal methods of correction become involved... There was a particularly glaring example of this in London recently when the final pianissimo D flat in a tiny clarinet interjection in Beethoven's Fifth came under the magnifier. It was sharp - predictably, because that's what happens to a clarinet when you do a special pianissimo. The player of course knew this, and the next time *Parkinson came around he played it just a reasonable piano in dynamic - in tune. The conductor (not a wind player of course) wasn't happy at the solution. He wanted pp, so he got pp, and sharp. he then made the obvious suggestion of any fiddler - taking another 'A' from the oboe. What this as supposed to achieve was quite obscure, because the fixing of that 'A' on the clarinet could bear no relation to the D flat, which is an overblown harmonic on a part of the tube and not affected in any way by the adjustment of the 'A'. The player knew this - it was his job to know it. The conductor didn't nor could he be expected to have the intimate knowledge of acoustics of an overblown cylindrical tube with an attached single-beating reed, which was the basis of this little problem. So Parkinson did his worst, and a lot of valuable man-minutes were wasted on a problem which in fact needn't have existed, because the solution was quite simple. That afternoon, all the player had to do was to remove a couple of keys, clean out the tone hole for D flat, and insert carefully a tiny patch of sticky medical plaster before replacing the key... and upon such simple but far-reaching remedies do those Heaven-sent performances depend.
<< less
location of experience: London
Listeners
Jack Brymer
Schoolteacher, Clarinetist, Musician
1915-2003
Notes
*Parkinson here refers to Brymer's so-called Parkinson's Law: 'the law which says that the amount of work you have to do expands in proportion to the amount of time you have to do its completion' (In The Orchestra, p. 11)
Originally submitted by iepearson on Sat, 06 Dec 2014 15:20:45 +0000
Approved on Wed, 02 Mar 2016 11:45:17 +0000