Benjamin Lumley in Her Majesty's Theatre - 12 March, 1846

from Reminiscences of the Opera, pages 148-9:

On Tuesday the 12th of March, "I Lombardi," another opera by Signor Verdi, was given for the first time, with the names of Grisi, Mario, and Fornasari, and was illustrated by scenery and dresses, which at this period were considered unsurpassed. Here was again a success- nay, a great and noisy success — but yet a doubtful one. After the comparative unanimity with which "Nabucco" had been received, it seemed necessary for the forces of the opposition to recommence the attack against a school which now threatened to make its way with the town. Party spirit on the subject was again rife. Whilst, by the Anti-Verdians, "I Lombardi" was declared to be flimsy, trashy, worthless ; the Verdi party, and the adherents of the modern Italian school, pronounced it to be full of power, vigour, and originality. The one portion asserted that it was utterly devoid of melody — the other, that it was replete with melody of the most charming kind; the one again insisted that it was the worst work of the aspirant — the other, that it was the young composer's chef-d'oeuvre. And in the midst of this conflict — so analogous to the old feud between the partizans of Gluck and Piccini — public opinion, as usual, seemed undecided and wavering, uttering its old formula of "Well! I don't know!" The music, too, was weighed down by a rambling, ill-constructed, uninteresting libretto ; and it is really difficult, under such conditions, to sunder the merit of the musical "setting" from the demerit of the text. "I Lombardi," however, was played frequently, and even to crowded houses.

<< less
cite as

Benjamin Lumley, Reminiscences of the Opera (London, 1864), p. 148-9. https://led.kmi.open.ac.uk/entity/lexp/1438685629660 accessed: 28 November, 2022

location of experience: Her Majesty's Theatre

Listeners

Benjamin Lumley
Opera manager, Solicitor
1811-1875

Listening to

hide composers
I Lombardi
written by Giuseppe Verdi
performed by Luciano Fornasari, Giovanni Matteo Mario, Giulia Grisi

Experience Information

Date/Time 12 March, 1846
Medium live
Listening Environment in the company of others, indoors, in public

Originally submitted by sp327 on Tue, 04 Aug 2015 11:53:49 +0100
Approved on Sun, 24 Apr 2016 15:27:52 +0100