William Gardiner in Edinburgh - early 19th Century
from Music and Friends: Or, Pleasant Recollections of a Dilettante, pages 772-3:
The form of the service is precisely that of the old Presbyterians in England, in all respects the opposite to that of the episcopal church. The music, I ought to say singing, was execrable ; the first tune was begun by the clerk alone, the congregation falling in at the second line. All sorts of voices and sounds were blended together in unparalleled dissonance. The tune was Milton, in the key of G, and at the end of each line the tune fell a quarter of a note, so that by the time they drawled it out to the end of the verse, it had sunk to E flat.
William Gardiner, Music and Friends: Or, Pleasant Recollections of a Dilettante, volume 2 (London, January, 1838), p. 772-3. https://led.kmi.open.ac.uk/entity/lexp/1435608768292 accessed: 29 November, 2024
Listeners
Listening to
hide composersPresbyterian service |
Experience Information
Date/Time | early 19th Century |
Medium | live |
Listening Environment | in the company of others, in private, indoors |